Isla in Caramel

Super cute! Sized up from my usual size (10.5 or 11) to 12. Glad I did because length fit. They were still a bit narrow across my toes, but could be comfortable. I couldn’t zip them up all the way, so I returned them. I typically don’t need wide calf boots. I think this was my last try with CS- I love the designs, hate how the sizing is completely random.

These shoes are gorgeous and sturdy. I typically wear an 8, but for all Charlotte Stone shoes I have sized up to a 9 due to the width of my foot. So far, that has solved any issues. The fit on my foot is fine. However, upon first attempt a little dehydrated after a long weekend, I could not zip up the boots all the way. My calves aren't dainty but I'd say they are average?

I tried later in the week and got them all the way zipped. Just barely and it's not a very flattering look, or very comfortable. I am debating keeping them because otherwise I am in love and I may just try to stretch them out? But for the price (and also inclusivity's sake) that shouldn't need to happen.

Ugh! Soooo cute and can tell they are really comfortable but only made for skinny legged people. Could not zip up all the way (a whole two inches away from being zipped up). Even sized up based on recommendations. Really wished they fit!

I’m obsessed with the look of these boots. The chunky sole is fabulous, the fabric is gorgeous. BUT like other reviewers I found these comically narrow - I could bare fit my foot into the shoe! I wear a 9.5W and usually am fine in a Charlotte stone 10. So bummed because these are otherwise lovely and with a little redesigning I would 100% buy these again but sadly I’ll be returning mine

Okay, first of all - these shoes are just as amazing in person as they look online. Also, they seem comfortable for walking when I tried them on, but I haven't been able to try them out for walks yet because I need to return them for sizing issues. Now, to the sizing... Like most Charlotte Stone shoes these are narrow. If you have wide feet, you'll need to size up or decide that you think you can break them in enough and be willing to do that. I wear a 9 in shows because technically my feet are an "8.6" and slightly wide. In most show brands, a 9 fits me. In Charlotte Stone, a 9 will usually fit lengthwise, but be tight across the toe box and I will either choose to stretch them or exchange them for a 10 depending on how tight they are. But these... they are so tight in the instep that I had to force my foot into them - genuinely thought I wasn't going to get it in there. Additionally, once my feet were in, they were short enough that I was acutely aware of the heel counter pressing against my heel. All that to say, this is the first pair of Charlotte Stones that I have bought where the width wasn't the only reason for me to size up. All that being said, they are completely worth it and I am exchanging for a 10 and I will be wearing these everywhere this fall.